Prove What They Say

Lesson Plan - Get It!

Audio:

Both of the above quotes are about how having proof of what you say gives your words power.

Without that proof, it is hard to believe what is being said.

• If someone told you there was 100 feet of snow outside, would you immediately believe them?
• Or would you want proof -- like looking outside yourself or seeing a photo?

Proof matters!

When people speak to share their ideas and thoughts, their goal is to make others believe them, understand them, or think the same we they do.

To do that, they must give reasons for why they think the way they do. The more reasons given, the more likely others are to agree.

Being able to listen closely to speakers and recognize their reasons is an important skill. It allows you to understand how they are supporting their point, and it will help you make believable points when you are speaking.

• So, what are reasons?

Reasons serve as proof and include:

• evidence
• clues
• support
• details

• How can speakers share these reasons?

Speakers can support what they are saying with:

• written text with facts
• pictures
• specific examples
• real-life events that happened to them
• things everyone can understand and relate to

Think about when you read something. For it to make sense, there needs to be main ideas and supporting details.

The same is true when speaking!

Just like the supporting details make you believe a writer's main ideas, the reasons make you believe a speaker's main ideas.

Let's look at another example.

While I am speaking to you, I say, "There is a lot of green in nature."

• Do you believe me?

You might. However, if I listed examples of green in nature, like trees and grass, you would be more likely to believe me.

• What if I showed you photos or took you outside and showed you all the green in nature?

Those reasons would definitely support you believing me!

So, we know that speakers give us reasons to support and prove what they're saying, but the work isn't all on them.

As listeners, we need to listen with intention (or on purpose!) to figure out the points that the speaker is making. We also need to listen specifically for the reasons and evidence that back up those points.

Move on to the Got It? section to practice this topic together!