Pyrrho Versus Bill Nye the Science Guy

Contributor: Brian Anthony. Lesson ID: 12850

Do you ever wish life were just a big dream and you'll some day wake up and everything will be fine? How do you know it's not a dream, or know that you don't know it's a dream or not? Better read on!

categories

World Cultures

subject
Social Studies
learning style
Visual
personality style
Otter, Golden Retriever
Grade Level
Middle School (6-8)
Lesson Type
Dig Deeper

Lesson Plan - Get It!

Audio:

What is one thing you know one-hundred percent for sure? Maybe your brain is in a laboratory vat and the world you know is a computer-generated fantasy. Whoa! Freak me out!

The great seventeenth-century thinker Rene Descartes (pronounced /day cart/) was bothered by something: He imagined that maybe the world was an illusion created by a demon, just to deceive him.

He felt like the world around him was real, like there were objects and people, events and feelings.

  • How could he be one-hundred percent sure about any of them, though?
  • How could he prove without any doubt that anything really existed?

Surely, we all notice times when our senses deceive us. Take a moment and make a list of experiences in which our mind plays tricks on us.

  • How many can you come up with?

It turns out the list of illusions is pretty long.

  • Dreams are a big example, and we have all experienced dreams that we were completely convinced were real. Sometimes, even after waking, it takes a few moments to accept that we were fooled by our sleeping mind.
  • The “colors” we see are only a tiny portion of the full range of the full spectrum of light, and not everyone perceives these colors to be the same.
  • In social situations, we can imagine a friend to be hostile or angry towards us, but it turns out to be completely untrue.
  • Then there is the old spoon-in-a-glass-of-water illusion in which the spoon appears to be split in two.

Here is a question to reflect upon; write your response in your notebook or journal:

  • How can you prove, beyond any doubt whatsoever, that you are not dreaming right now?

That is a tough question — and you may think a silly one — but it's one many philosophers have struggled with over the centuries.

In the Got It? section, discover an answer to that question that you can believe one-hundred percent without any doubt whatsoever.

Elephango's Philosophy

We help prepare learners for a future that cannot yet be defined. They must be ready for change, willing to learn and able to think critically. Elephango is designed to create lifelong learners who are ready for that rapidly changing future.